Agentic AI and MCP for Product Managers
Prompt Library: Checking Yourself
Do You Actually Need an Agent?
Help me work out whether an agent is right, or whether something simpler is better. THE TASK:
[description]. HOW A HUMAN DOES IT TODAY: [walk through]. DOES THE PATH VARY: [how much].
ACTIONS INVOLVED: [read, write, irreversible]. CONSEQUENCE OF A WRONG ACTION: [honestly]. CAN
WE CAPTURE FULL TRACES: [yes/no/don't know]. Tell me directly: is this a button, a workflow,
or an agent, pick one, don't hedge. If an agent, what's the lowest autonomy level that still
delivers most of the value? Is there a version where a workflow handles 80% of cases and an
agent only the awkward ones? What would have to be true for an agent to be clearly right, and
is it true here? And if we built it and it underperformed, what's the most likely reason?
Don't be encouraging.