Question 1

What is a product council?

Accepted Answer

A cross-functional group of senior stakeholders who meet regularly to set strategic product direction, allocate resources, and make high-stakes decisions a single team cannot resolve entirely on its own.

Question 2

Who is credited with originating the product council concept?

Accepted Answer

The concept is credited to Maynard Webb, eBay’s former COO, and was significantly popularized in modern product circles by Marty Cagan of Silicon Valley Product Group.

Question 3

What is the central tension a product council has to manage?

Accepted Answer

Providing genuine oversight and strategic direction from leadership without that oversight sliding into leadership directly designing the product, which disempowers the product team.

Question 4

What is the clearest test for which decisions belong in front of a product council?

Accepted Answer

Whether the decision is genuinely difficult or costly to reverse. Hard-to-reverse, high-stakes decisions belong in front of the council; easily reversible, low-stakes decisions do not.

Question 5

What are the four milestones a product council typically reviews?

Accepted Answer

Reviewing proposed strategy and initiating an opportunity assessment; reviewing that assessment for a go/no-go on specification; reviewing a prototype and testing results for a go/no-go on engineering; and reviewing the final product and launch plans for a go/no-go to launch.

Question 6

How large should a product council be?

Accepted Answer

Commonly ten members or fewer, since a larger group slows decision-making considerably and dilutes genuine ownership among attendees.

Question 7

How often should a product council meet?

Accepted Answer

Commonly monthly, though larger, more mature organizations sometimes shift to a quarterly cadence, with the right frequency scaling to company size and product lifecycle stage.

Question 8

What is a common mistake in running a product council?

Accepted Answer

Routing low-stakes, easily reversible decisions through the process purely out of habit, which dilutes the council’s real value and slows the organization down without genuine benefit.

Question 9

Should a product manager and engineering lead bring an unresolved disagreement to the council for the first time?

Accepted Answer

No. Surfacing a disagreement they had never discussed beforehand signals a failure of preparation, not a genuine need for council input, and undermines confidence in the presenting team.

Question 10

Is a product council the same thing as a customer or product advisory board?

Accepted Answer

No. A product council is an internal, decision-making body of company stakeholders, while a customer or product advisory board is an external group of customers gathered specifically for feedback.

What Is a Product Council? When Do You Need One?

Learn better with active recall quiz

Q1: What is a product council?

Frequently Asked Questions